Brian Hickey | Aug 19 2025 15:00
In today's digital age, where texting has become second nature, it's normal to feel anxious about how our digital lives can affect us legally. It's crucial to understand how and when texts can be used against us in court, and what steps we can take to protect ourselves.
Texts as Evidence
Text messages can indeed serve as evidence in court, but they must first meet certain admissibility standards. A text’s authenticity
needs to be confirmed, meaning it should be linked to a specific device or account. Moreover, the text must be relevant
to the case and comply with evidentiary rules and legal procedures.
Screenshots Limitations
Screenshots alone often fall short of standing as valid evidence because they can be easily edited or misrepresented. Courts usually prefer the original messages complete with full metadata, which can provide context and authenticity.
How Innocent Messages Can Be Misinterpreted
It's alarming but true: even innocent messages can be misinterpreted. Jokes or vague comments taken out of context may be twisted to support a narrative different from what you intended, making it all the more critical to think before texting.
Privacy Isn't Guaranteed
Despite the perceived privacy of texting, messages can be accessed in multiple ways. Law enforcement may acquire them through a warrant, they might be retrieved from phone providers' metadata, or they might be stored on someone else's device. Hence, it's essential to maintain awareness of the traces you leave.
Recovering Deleted Messages
Beware that even deleted texts might still be recoverable, especially if law enforcement accesses the device early. Avoid tampering or attempting to erase texts, as it may lead to further complications.
Challenging Text Message Evidence
If faced with text message evidence against you, remember that it can be disputed. Common defense strategies include arguing improper procedure, providing context to the messages, or denying authorship. This highlights the importance of challenging the narrative and ensuring your side of the story is heard.
Preventive Measures
Prevention is always better than cure. Before sending sensitive texts, consider the consequences and ensure your phone and messaging applications are secured. After an incident, refrain from deleting any messages as it could be seen as an attempt to destroy evidence.
While it's concerning that texts can be used in court, remember that knowledge is power. Digital evidence can be disputed, and there is always legal assistance available. If you're uncertain about how your messages might be interpreted legally, consult a defense attorney for guidance.